SHARE
FacebookEmailShare

Partners in Predation


America and Israel After the Cold War

Abdul El-Sayed wants to be the first Muslim in the US Senate, and his views on Israel, Palestine, and foreign policy are drawing fire.

Goethe in the Holy Land. Shouk Hacarmel, Tel Aviv.
Goethe in the Holy Land. Shouk Hacarmel, Tel Aviv.

In a recent debate, El-Sayed was asked if he thought Israel was a bigger threat to the United States than Iran.

“I think both of them have proven dangerous in their own way. One at risk of attacking us, one getting us into wars we have no business fighting,” he responded.

However, one clearly sees the folly of American policy toward Iran—and recognises that the United States and Israel have attacked Iran twice without provocation, and a third attack appears imminent—the US is now at war with the Islamic Republic.

By definition, Iran is an enemy. But is Israel really an ally?

American Decisions Meet Israeli Obstinacy

It has long been a cliché in American foreign policy that Israel is the United States’ closest ally and its most dependable partner in the Middle East.

Yet, like so many foreign policy principles, this assertion is rarely scrutinised, even as conditions change.

During the Cold War, there was a clear, albeit debatable, case for the alliance with Israel.

In the 1950s and 1960s, Gamal Abdel Nasser’s pan-Arab and Egyptian nationalism led Westerners to worry that he was both too independent and too accommodating to the Soviet Union.

Along with Syria, Iraq, South Yemen, Libya, and Algeria, many Arab states fell within or near the USSR’s sphere of influence.

Israel, though initially seeking to balance Washington and Moscow, was moving towards the American camp by the early 1960s.

When it struck a decisive blow against Egypt and Syria in 1967, destroying Nasser’s image in the Arab world, Israel was elevated to a much closer partnership with Washington.

When the Cold War ended, however, the rationale for the alliance was no longer clear.

Why was the United States giving billions to Israel despite its strong economy, propping up Jordanian and Egyptian dictatorships because of their treaties with Israel, and shielding Israel’s aggression, violations of international law, and human rights abuses?

The answer was layered. Some argued that Israel was indispensable in the War on Terror. But the overriding appeal was not a policy idea; it was an ideological one.

The notion of “shared values” has underpinned American support for the special relationship with Israel for the past three decades.

The idea is that we share values of democracy, freedom, and equality. Yet neither the United States nor, certainly, Israel lives up to these ideals.

We need only look at the Palestinians to see how Israel fails that test.

We need not even go as far as Gaza: Masafer Yatta, any other Palestinian village in the West Bank, or Palestinian neighbourhoods in East Jerusalem are enough.

Even Palestinian cities in the West Bank reflect the scars of occupation and the poverty caused by Israel’s deliberate crushing of the Palestinian economy.

We can also look at the many neglected communities in the US, the enormous rate of incarceration and barbaric prison conditions, and the extreme concentration of wealth.

This leaves tens of millions impoverished, while those who manage to get by must work long hours and live with constant stress just to pay rent and feed their families.

That is before we even get to the issues of racism and the ever-increasing persecution of immigrants.

The case for shared values is real; it just isn’t the case that most Americans and Israelis want to make. The shared values are dispossession; racism; increasing oligarchy and corruption; and genocide past and present.

What of strategic interests?

Israel provides intelligence to the United States, but that intelligence is notoriously unreliable, often shaded, selected, or even manufactured to promote Israel’s interests.

Recent legislation introduced to grant Israel unprecedented access to American intelligence demonstrates that the value of intelligence sharing between the two countries is far greater for Israel than for the United States.

Israel no longer functions as a “cop on the beat” as it once did. Historical Israeli interventions in places like Jordan or Iraq are a thing of the past.

Few Arab states, regardless of their other political positions, want to risk an Israeli military presence. Saudi Arabia’s recent refusal of Israeli help despite its immense difficulties in handling the attacks by Ansar Allah reflects this new reality.

If Israel offers few strategic advantages, why is the relationship of such seemingly immense value?

The answer lies in the unprecedented partnership between American corporations, their Israeli counterparts and the Israeli government itself.

In the tech and defence sectors, American corporations benefit enormously from the flow of cash to Israel and the additional cash that goes to Egypt, Jordan, and other Middle East locations.

Apart from a small percentage of American aid to Israel, all money contributed by the American taxpayer to the Middle East must be spent in the United States.

Moreover, Congress has funded many joint research and manufacturing projects that siphon even more taxpayer dollars into the coffers of Israeli and American corporations.

Much of the direct funding may be spent in the US, but Israelis often benefit from proprietary control over the end results, allowing them to sell the technology and weaponry to other countries, helping to fuel Israel’s booming defence industry.

It’s a win-win for wealthy shareholders at the expense of both American taxpayers and American foreign policy.

This dynamic both powers and is enormously energised by the pro-Israel lobby. In many ways, this lobby functions as much as an arm of the defence and technology sector as it does as an ideological steamroller pushing Israel’s interests.

The fact that this aspect benefits the more coldly and greedily pragmatic sectors of the American oligarchy shields the entire system from accusations of betraying American interests in favour of Israel’s.

American Involvement in Middle East Wars

Greed drives the alliance, while the pro-Israel lobby and advocacy provide the ideological rationale for US support for Israel.

This support continues despite there being no strategic rationale for backing Israel’s occupations of Southern Lebanon and Syria, or for its alleged ethnic cleansing, apartheid, and genocide against Palestinians in the occupied West Bank and Gaza.

Indeed, all those Israeli actions significantly complicate American foreign policy goals in the region.

We should not mistake those goals for altruism.

Although a popular national movement like the Palestinians’ has little chance of succeeding, the instability caused by Israel’s crimes and its total abandonment of even the pretence of a Palestinian state complicates everything the United States tries to accomplish in the region.

This includes its now-comatose effort to pivot its attention towards Asia.

Yet El-Sayed’s formulation is flippant and inaccurate. The idea that Israel “got us into” this war with Iran is a vast oversimplification.

Yes, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu used his many face-to-face meetings with Donald Trump to sell the president on attacking Iran.

Bibi had tried to convince every president since George W. Bush to do it. None of them was stupid or gullible enough to acquiesce.

But Israel did not force the US leader’s hand. This was very much his decision.

Trump was captivated by his swift victory in Venezuela and by visions of becoming the president who finally settled Iran’s hash after 47 years.

The ridiculous narrative from US Secretary of State Marco Rubio in February that Israel was going to attack Iran regardless of American intentions and desires, so that Washington struck first to forestall Iranian retaliation against American targets, is threadbare and obvious.

The same retaliation occurred as would have occurred if Israel had acted alone.

More to the point, the idea that Israel could do such a thing without an American green light, given that Washington is where the weapons and money come from, is absurd.

That was proven earlier this month when Israel abandoned a plan to rekindle the war on Iran when Trump baulked.

This harks back as well to the Iraq war and the notion that it too was an Israeli war forced on the United States. It was not.

The neoconservative voices leading us into that war were staunch supporters of Israel, yet their vision was of Israel as the local enforcer for an American empire that fully controlled the Middle East.

But as strongly pro-Israel as they were, they were primarily an American movement and saw themselves as such.

Neocons believed that “we cannot safely avoid the responsibilities of global leadership or the costs that are associated with its exercise. America has a vital role in maintaining peace and security in Europe, Asia, and the Middle East. If we shirk our responsibilities, we invite challenges to our fundamental interests.”

Those ideas, an aggressive, domineering foreign policy, which they called “Reaganite” with good reason, inform the Trump Administration today, just as they did the previous Republican president, George W. Bush.

It is a fundamentally American decision, and a distinctly American conceit.

Given the massive decline in American power that followed the neoconservative ideology’s implementation in the War on Terror, it took a president as corrupt, megalomaniacal, and still as ignorant as Trump to revive the doctrine.

But there is no doubt that these policies are embraced and strongly encouraged by Israel. They are also embraced and encouraged by much more powerful sectors of the American economy.

Without Israel, the United States would still be a declining empire, succumbing to its own hubris and an unrestrained oligarchic capitalist system.

But that doesn’t change the fact that Israel wields considerable influence in American politics in pursuit of its own interests—interests that often clash strategically with those of the United States and run counter to the wishes of most Americans.

One can debate how much harm Israel causes the United States and how much is self-inflicted. But Israel offers the US very little, while making it much harder for Americans to pursue a foreign policy that rejects dictators, apartheid, genocide, and war.

The US has plenty of problems of its own, and Israel only adds to them.

That’s not what an ally should do.

Photograph courtesy of Joel Schalit. All rights reserved.