SHARE
FacebookEmailShare

Making Arab Voters the Enemy


Netanyahu’s Election Playbook and What it Costs Israel

Voting in the Israeli elections has concluded. As of this writing, most votes have been counted.

Palestinian Israelis. Rehov Allenby, Tel Aviv.
Palestinian Israelis. Rehov Allenby, Tel Aviv.

The shape of the next Knesset is clear.

Benjamin Netanyahu’s bloc has won fifty-three seats, while the Zionist opposition has taken forty-eight.

Israel’s Palestinian Arab parties hold the remaining nineteen seats.

Given the dismal pre-election polls, you might expect Bibi and his Likud Party—which won more seats than any other party—to be pleased.

But coalition politics paint a grim picture for both sides. If the political stalemate continues, Netanyahu remains in power as the incumbent.

Instead, the Likud issued a scathing statement accusing Israel’s Palestinian parties of “stealing” the election through widespread election fraud, bribery, and intimidation, magnifying the dread and fear Israel’s Palestinian citizens are already feeling.

Likud stated, in part:

The elections in the State of Israel were stolen by Arab parties that support terrorism and the destruction of the Jewish state, through serious criminal offenses involving bribery, threats, violence, fraud, and the use of prohibited software to mobilize voters… We demand that the police and the Shin Bet conduct a thorough investigation into the theft of the elections by the Arab parties and ensure that those responsible are brought to justice.

According to Israeli police, there is no evidence to substantiate Likud’s wild accusations. But that will not necessarily prevent them from having an inciting effect on a large right-wing Israeli population that finds itself incapable of sustaining a majority in the Knesset after four years in power.

Allegations of foreign interference, linked to Qatar, don’t help. Such tactics seem less like a reaction to the result and more like a planned response.

Even as the election started, Israeli police arrested three Bedouin citizens because they had envelopes with cash and voting slips.

Police claimed this proved bribery was afoot, though it is unclear what exactly the authorities allege.

The Bedouins are activists with the United Arab List (Ra’am) party, a conservative Arab party that was a member of Israel’s short-lived government under Naftali Bennett and Yair Lapid in 2021 and 2022.

Ra’am objected vociferously to the arrest, saying, “The activists were arrested in their homes, hours before the polling stations opened, and not near polling stations or voters. These are false arrests intended to suppress voting in the Arab community, as part of National Security Minister Ben-Gvir’s political use of the Israel Police.”

It is telling that Israeli authorities went after Ra’am rather than Palestinian citizens affiliated with the Joint List, which is far more vocal about the rights of Palestinians living under Israeli occupation in the West Bank and Gaza.

Shades of 6 January 2021 in the US

Likud’s accusations echo those of Donald Trump in 2020 after he lost the presidential election, and even in 2016, when he won.

In those cases, Trump primarily targeted non-citizen migrants. This laid the groundwork for policies of intense persecution of immigrants, mass deportations, and the imprisonment of minorities in horrifically inhumane conditions, despite having committed no crimes.

Violence against Palestinian citizens of Israel is not as common as in the West Bank, but the election has stoked fears of significant escalation.

As he had in previous elections, Netanyahu stoked these fears before and during the campaign by demonising Israel’s Arab population. On election day, he urged his right-wing supporters to turn out and vote, warning that if they do not, they will get a “government of the Muslim Brotherhood”.

That language, which has brought accusations of racism against Republicans in the United States when they used it against candidate for Senate Abdul El-Sayed, is far more dangerous in Israel.

Although Hamas is no longer affiliated with the Muslim Brotherhood and the Brotherhood has turned away from violence, forty years ago Hamas began as the Brotherhood’s Palestinian branch—a fact most Israelis know.

In the post-7 October world, this is explosive incitement.

Ironically, most of the actions Likud accuses the Arab parties of taking to “rig the election” appear to be actions that Likud and other right-wing parties have taken themselves.

According to reports, the Central Elections Committee will investigate accusations of “vote tallying” at 115 polling stations across Israel. This refers to election workers counting votes and reporting the results to party leaders. Israel’s High Court ruled the practice illegal just last month.

But that was only the beginning.

Numerous polling stations in Arab districts were targeted by violent young Jewish settlers seeking to intimidate voters, while some Arab polling stations mysteriously ran out of ballots with Arabic translations and were not allowed to replenish them.

The irrational fear of and racism toward Israel’s Palestinian citizens, fuelled by these accusations from Likud, are precursors to something much worse.

Many might dismiss that idea as bombast, recalling Netanyahu’s infamous call in an earlier election for his supporters to get to the polls because the “Arabs are voting in droves.”

But much more is going on here.

In late August, the Religious Zionism party, led by the infamous Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich, announced Smotrich’s plan to Judaize the Galilee and the Negev, two areas where Israel’s Arab citizenry is concentrated.

The party stated that the “national program for the Judaization of the Negev and the Galilee” is intended to “bring the revolution [Smotrich] led in recent years in Judea and Samaria to these regions”.

In other words, they intend to expand Jewish neighbourhoods in those areas and squeeze out the Palestinians living there, by means both legal and otherwise, just as they have done on the West Bank.

Smotrich’s words contributed to the record turnout among Israel’s Palestinian citizens, despite the far-right’s efforts to suppress them.

Ironically, they probably also boosted his own appeal, which was so low at the time of his statement that he was forced to form a joint ticket with another far-right party, Zehut or risk falling below the electoral threshold for the Knesset.

Targeting the Most Moderate

The hated “Arab parties” are by no means monolithic.

Hadash is a communist party; Balad is an explicitly anti-Zionist party that is founded on its intention to transform Israel into a state of all its citizens; Ta’al is also an explicitly anti-Zionist and nationalistic party, more radical than Ta’al.

Together they form the Joint List.

Ra’am, also known as the United Arab List, is an Islamist, conservative party that distinguishes itself from the Joint List parties by avoiding significant involvement with the question of the occupation of the West Bank and Gaza.

Rather, Ra’am sees its role as working within the Israeli system to advance its agenda: securing funding for Israel’s Arab communities and promoting conservative religious values.

Yet Netanyahu and his right-wing allies direct much of their venom at the moderate Ra’am party. The three Bedouin activists who were arrested belonged to the party.

This is no accident. The message to Israel’s Arab sector is that the right has no tolerance for them and that they are not safe in Israel—a message that was certainly received.

On the Other Side

The desperation Netanyahu has created among Israelis outside his right-wing coalition is what unites the Zionist opposition.

The problem is that this is about all they agree on, and one of their sharpest disagreements is whether Palestinian parties would be welcome as partners.

Yair Golan, leader of The Democrats party, sees the danger of the opposition’s unwillingness to work with the Arab parties.

“We have no future here if we don’t stop being afraid,” he wrote on Twitter. “And if we don’t stop with the racism. We must no longer accept Netanyahu’s racist division between Jewish votes and Arab votes. The voice of an Israeli citizen voting in Taybeh (an Arab town in Israel) is worth exactly as much as the voice of an Israeli citizen voting in Givat Shmuel (a Jewish city). No less. Not approximately. Exactly.”

The sentiment is spot-on, but the chances of Golan’s advice being heeded are slim. Opposition leader Gadi Eisenkot vowed not to join with the Arab parties during the campaign.

While some of his coalition partners, such as Golan and Yair Lapid, may be willing to compromise that principle to remove Netanyahu from office, others—particularly Naftali Bennett and Avigdor Lieberman—are far more explicitly racist and have built their reputations on it.

Lieberman is insisting he will not work with the Palestinian parties in any way. Bennett has not yet spoken about a potential coalition.

Even if Lieberman or Bennett might compromise on working with Ra’am, they would never agree to work with the explicitly anti-Zionist, pro-Palestinian Joint List.

This means the opposition cannot cobble together enough Knesset votes to form a majority or even a governing minority.

Moreover, even if they worked with the Joint List, Eisenkot, or any other opposition leader, they would have to grapple with the concern that any coalition, even if supported from outside, is unlikely to endure.

That would bring Israel back to another election, which would also happen if no bloc can form a majority coalition in the Knesset.

The difference, and it is a big one, is that if the opposition forms a government, even if it falls the next day, they get to be the caretakers during the next round of elections rather than Netanyahu.

It is fair to say, as many—myself included—have, that an Eisenkot-led coalition might not differ much from a Netanyahu-led one in Gaza and the West Bank.

But it is very much the case that it would act very differently toward Palestinian citizens of Israel.

It might even feel the need to try to win back some of the global support it lost by easing up on Palestinians under occupation.

But even if it simply means preventing Smotrich, Ben Gvir, and Netanyahu from turning the Galilee and the Negev into a West Bank, it’s a worthwhile goal.

At least until we do more to change Israel’s apartheid nature and its broader warmongering and genocidal behaviour.

 Photograph courtesy of Joel Schalit. All rights reserved.